@Heroid here.
I remember you, Kelp! I'll never forget you!
I've tried TSW, CO, DCUO, AoC, and none of them are what I'm looking for.
TSW comes closest, I guess, because the stories in the game are good, but there's just too much running around killing zombies for me and I never got past the low levels. It might help if I could find the "Gemini Park" of the Secret World, but I don't even know if it exists.
CO feels like a video game in a way that CoH never did and the same with DCUO.
As for Conan or any other fantasy game -- sadly, I find that running around with a sword hacking at monsters is as tedious as shooting zombies.
So, I'm not playing anything.
IF CoH gets revived, OR if one of the Project Z games manages to capture enough of that flavor AND there is a great rp community in any of those situations, I'll be ready to take to the streets (or the skies) to fight evil beside you all once again.
In the meantime, I come here to lurk in the shadows and relive the old days. It's a much better comfort than I've found in trying to replace City of Heroes.