Forum Game: The stockings were hung by the [chimney] with [care].

[Pengy]

We secretly replaced their coffee with enormous elephants. Let's see if they notice.

[Paragon Avenger]

We secretly replaced their coffee with French Floosies, let's see if they notice.

[Pengy]

We secretly replaced their coffee with ground ginger. Let's see if they notice.

[Paragon Avenger]

We secretly replaced their coffee with hot horseradish, let's see if they notice.

[Floride]

We secretly replaced their coffee with inferior infidels, let's see if they notice.

[Pengy]

We secretly replaced their coffee with jolly Jack-in-Irons. Let's see if they notice.

[SerialBeggar]

We secretly replaced their coffee with Kentucky ketchup.  Let's see if they notice.

[healix]

We secretly replaced their coffee with liquid liver.  Let's see if they notice.

[Pengy]

We secretly replaced their coffee with maloventy maldemer.  Let's see if they notice.

No, I don't know what maloventy means, but anyone who played a text adventure has probably encountered it.

[Floride]

We secretly replaced their coffee with non-drowsy Nyquil.  Let's see if they notice.

[SerialBeggar]

We secretly replaced their coffee with opalescent ooze.  Let's see if they notice.

[Paragon Avenger]

We secretly replaced their coffee with poisonous puss; let's see if they notice.

[SerialBeggar]

We secretly replaced their coffee with a quiffed quiche.  Let's see if they notice.

[Paragon Avenger]

We secretly replaced their coffee with rotten rum; let's see if they notice.

[SerialBeggar]

We secretly replaced their coffee with Syracuse slush.  Let's see if they notice.

[Paragon Avenger]

We secretly replaced their coffee with tainted tuna; let's see if they notice.

[Pengy]

We secretly replaced their coffee with unwashed undergarments; let's see if they notice.

[Paragon Avenger]

We secretly replaced their coffee with violence victims; let's see if they notice.

[Floride]

We secretly replaced their coffee with warm wine; let's see if they notice.

[Paragon Avenger]

We secretly replaced their coffee with xenomorph x-rays; let's see if they notice.