The problem with drawing a hard line is you eventually find yourself bumping into it. Also, NCsoft wants to get paid and dust their hands, not do more work. Who knows what shape their user account data is in, they may not be able to provide it, may be against legal limitations within their own country, have competing interests preventing sharing the data, who knows?
Exactly.
The more NCSoft has to provide, the more pricey it will be. That's kind of why I am resigning myself to character loss. I just don't think we are going to get our old alts back. [Please let me be wrong!] the most important thing IMO is getting the game back, period.
I think one problem here is, that many people including myself, saw our alts as our property. We spent the time leveling them, we took them on a million TF/SFs, we are the ones who ponied up [in one way or another] for our rare enhancements, etc. NC didn't do that, we did it. I'll speak for myself: when the game closed, not only was I tremendously upset by the taking away of my online "home," I felt that NCSoft had broken faith with me and STOLEN actual ASSETS from me. "FREE FOREVER!" right?...? Well... maybe not. I was a fool to take them at their word.
Our alts were worth real-world money; people sold 'em on eBay, for instance. Many of my alts were carrying tens of millions of Influence. I even considered: what if you were only allowed access to, say, five of your alts? Who would they be? .... and I know who they would be. Just in case, you know.... and this was long before closure announcement.
So, when the game closed I didn't give all my cash away; my alts kept their money. I emptied base storage of all valuables, stashing it on my alts. I didn't log off in my SG bases on the last day, for fear of what might happen to a character parked in a place that might not even exist, were the game ever to come back. I did what I could, just in case; but I just don't see NC giving us that data.
I would pay all of my in-game assets just to run through the Underground trial map again.... and who knows, I might have to put my money where my mouth is. Its ok. I can do all that again. I HAVE done it again, when the game was up. I know I re-rolled my villain Main alt at least five times, in order to get powersets I felt comfortable with; and that was back before we could transfer assets via in-game mail. I respec'ed her countless times. It was all good; she was still THERE. As I deleted I would say, "you will be back soon, sweetie" and then I would remake her in her own image. AGAIN.
Can I do it again? You betcha. How sweet it would be to see her rise again on my screen, more beautiful than ever.