Everquest 2 was extraordinarily dull and tedious when last I played it. That was within months of release, so I can't vouch for any changes that may or may not have occurred.
Lord of the Rings Online was a bit less dull and tedious than it was during beta when last I played, which was before it went F2P (assuming my mind isn't betraying me and it did, in fact, go F2P). If one could put up with with the plodding pace (and, indeed, some people are far more acclimatized to such things than others) the setting is put together well and properly steeped in Tolkien lore from what I've seen.
Neverwinter is an incomplete action game. I like it, but I'm waiting for more classes to drop, more options for existing classes, some balance tweaks, etc. before I get back into it. In the meantime, I'm looking to try Dragon's Prophet.