I had several WDs die in quick succession somewhere around 2002-2004ish, swore them off, and have gone all Seagate since then without issue.
I've had two WDs die on me in November (which is why I was offline for the end-of-game event...) but I still prefer WD over other brands because they have FANTASTIC support. It's the only company that has a replacements center here in Argentina, and all I had to do was show up with the defective drive and an RMA printed from their website, and I left with a new harddisk in minutes. Then when *that* drive turned out to be defective as well, I was given a bigger drive in apology for the inconvenience.
Even if the failure rate is higher (and my sample size is too small to be significant) their excellent support makes up for it. Of course, I can say that because I keep multiple backups of everything. If I had actually lost data I would be in a worse mood about it.
Regarding the OP's problem: long ago, when all other options had been exhausted (just replacing the controller board didn't work), I did a platter transplant. Cleaned the heck out of a small room to try to get dust out of the way, worked inside some garbage bags while wearing a face mask, opened the dead drive and a very similar drive that was fully functional, and carefully put the platters from one disc in the other, being careful to veeery gently manipulate the read mechanism and platters. It worked; the disk was recognized with all the files inside perfectly intact. Which I immediately copied to another drive while feeling the king of the universe.
But if you can hear the platters spinning, just swapping the controller board is likely to do the trick.