The Secret World. Eluminaughty on Grim.
I gave Secret World a whirl also, in fact I think I saw you on Grim and sent you a message complimenting the name.

This would be about a month ago.
Secret World is pretty cool and engaging, only problem is the need to purchase and sub to play, but lots of us COX'ers have gone there.
Currently giving Secret World a short break while I try out:
1) Champions Online - looks decent, I would say its got the closest to 'CoX' feel, although as we know it's not going to be close *enough*.
2) World of Tanks - been at this for a year, Free2Play mostly, its not at all a substitute for CoX but it IS great, adrenalin-thumping combat action, so it makes for a good distraction while you are feeling bummed.
3) MechWarrior Online - another combat game, trying to like this one, somehow its not clicking for me yet but it is still in Beta. Can be a lot of fun at times tho!
4) I let my poor LotRO chars languish for too long while playing CoH and WoT, so will fire those back up again and see how the game looks (is it still only gorgeous, or is it now ULTRA-gorgeous?).
I hear Everquest and EQ2 both have F2P options now, I was a huge EQ addict back in the day (2000-2001ish) so I may try and look up the old passwords and give those a try.
As other people have suggested, I will probably get around to giving STO and SW:TOR a try, have read good reviews on them.
(GW2? Not even if you paid me to play and threatened to skin my eyeballs if I didn't.)
Keeping an eye on all the 'resurrect CoH' threads, have sent a couple letters, signed the petition, and looking for other options. Not sure where I will end up so will be watching for new developments.
Hugs to all and good journeys to ya!
Doctor Hugh
(MadBadger on WoT/MWO/some others)