What names would you grab for first if we're starting from scratch?

[Power Gamer]

Dirty Angelina

[Paragon Avenger]

Throckmorton P. Gilldersleeve

[Power Gamer]

Vile Vowtaker

[Floride]

Mama's Lil Devil

[Pengy]

The Mighty Morphine-Powered Rang Rester

[Paragon Avenger]

Super Gru
The Gru Avenger
Gru Junior
Gru Hero
Gru Dude
Gru Guy
King Gru
Gru Man

[Power Gamer]

The Mendicant

[Paragon Avenger]

Eagle Man
Eagle Dude
Eagle Boy
Eagle Bot
Eagle Avenger
Eagle Warrior
Super Fire Eagle

[Pengy]

Glimmer Genocide, the Ponified Horror

[Paragon Avenger]

Pengy Avenger
Pengy Dragon
Super Pengy
Mr. Pengy
Pengy-bot
Robo-Pengy
Pengy Dengy
Pengy and the Wretch

[Castegyre]

Nickelback Cumberbatch
Cake Blanchett
Mighty Mighty Bjorktones
Rodney Danger Danger
Vincent (artist formally known as Prince)
Dinosaur Gooding Jr

[Pengy]

Friendly Mr. Grenade

[Paragon Avenger]

Dumber Wolf

[Rejolt]

George Arr Arr Martin

Undead pirate mastermind

[Pengy]

The Demon Core - demon summoning mastermind
The Time Paste Pot Pete - earth control/time manipulation

[Paragon Avenger]

The Unnamed Server

[Nyghtshade]

Nyghtshade
Celtic Honor
Ice Kat

Hmmm, kind of curious as to why you'd grab another player's names...

[Pengy]

Ransoming them for your convenience, like that guy on the official forums toward the end.
Dibs on:
Cat Shade
Celtics Night
Honor Ice

[Nyghtshade]

Ransoming them for your convenience, like that guy on the official forums toward the end.
Dibs on:
Cat Shade
Celtics Night
Honor Ice

Probably a shame for them, then, that Paragon Chat will permit multiple players to use the same names.  So, no sale there.   :D

[Photon Cannon]

Probably a shame for them, then, that Paragon Chat will permit multiple players to use the same names.  So, no sale there.   :D

Just imagine a clone-based character. You could have five or more of the same exact thing running around...This could either be hilarious or outright disastrous.