I forgot to post in this topic way back when it was first started. At the time, I could log in just fine at the time, so I assumed the issue was for people who had only CoH on their account. Before I posted just now, I went to verify I could log in - I couldn't, and got the same error. However, I had tried logging in with my username - logging in with my email in the account name field worked just fine, and I can see my account info. In both cases, I got emails saying I was logging in from an unknown IP.
Just thought I'd share for those that do want to log in.