If you want to be consistent with what has been established, different pages for both versions of the badge
Explorer and Obsessed as an example
Yeah, that's our established method. That being said, since badges can change names with side-switching now functional, this might be the time to take a step back and ask ourselves, "Is this how we really want to continue to proceed? Or is there a better, more maintainable approach?"
I'm not uncomfortable continuing as we have in the past here. I
do think we might save ourselves a lot of extra work if we move to using a single article for each unique settitle identifier with an "Alternate Names" (or something similar) section that shows all of the possible names of the badge depending on your current alignment.
For example, in the case of Explorer and Obsessed, we would redirect Obsessed to Explorer. We would then add a table in a new subsection that looked something like
this.
Just food for thought at the moment.
(I don't think we should combine articles for badges with different settitle numbers even if they're very similar because the game is definitely differentiating between the two.)