I liked the first three with Tobey.
The first reboot one with Garfield was ok but the 2nd one was a real stinker for me.
I hated Tobey's first movie, kinda liked the second, and thought the third could've been good had it focused solely on the Sandman and totally left out That 70s Venom.
I didn't see Garfield's first Spider-Man movie until well after it was available to rent. I was pleasantly surprised, but the trailers for the sequel destroyed any good will I had towards his stint as the webhead.
I refuse to be optimistic about the upcoming movie. I will treat it with the same wariness as a DC movie, operating under the premise that no matter how promising it looks in the trailers it's likely to be terrible enough that all the good parts make the bad parts that much worse.